REVIEW: From FilmsActu “Good news for fans of romantic movies”

Thank you Alexandra1016 for the translation. From

 Another Water for Elephants review, this one from @FilmsActu: “Good news for fans of romantic movies, Water for Elephants respects the rules of the genre perfectly. A simple hero, a femme fatale trapped with a tyrannical husband, an impossible love… all the ingredients are there to make this new film directed by Francis Lawrence a success, especially due to its dream cast. Water for Elephants is a suprising turn for the director of Constantine and I Am Legend. The fears about his unfamiliarity with the romantic genre were understandable but in this movie he quickly proves that he has understood the expectations of his new audience.

Water for Elephants proportions perfectly the ingredients needed to make a traditional romantic movie without adding too much sweetness into the mix. However, one could be put off by the opening: an old man telling his story, narrating it as a voice-over – the opening is in fact the only bad thing about the film. Once the film takes us into the past of the hero, Jacob (Robert Pattinson) the story shifts without difficulty into a well constructed classic scenario based not only on romantic issues but also on the nomad universe in which the characters evolve. A universe that Lawrence chose to convey not through the prism of baroque fantasy or dreams but with realism, with all the social misery that the period of the Great Depression entailed. The metaphorical dimension of the train whose employees have become useless is inescapable. This is the context in which Robert Pattinson plays the archetypal character of an educated young man turned outcast following the death of his parents who becomes a foreigner in his own world and decides to abandon it. As you might expect, he falls in love with Marlena (Reese Witherspoon), the wife of August (Christoph Waltz), the violent and unstable boss.

With ambitious art direction, the charm of Water for Elephants obviously also rests on its cast: Robert Pattinson and Reese Witherspoon form a very cute couple on screen. Getting away from Twilight and recently seen in Remember Me, Robert Pattinson proves in this film that his talent is not limited to portraying handsome hunks and makes a very endearing Jacob, armed with his boyish smile. However Francis Lawrence sometimes misses opportunities for sensuality in the scenes between the hero and his partner. The filmmaker manages to raise tensions at the height of the love triangle, with Christoph Waltz excelling in the role of the powerful psychopath who is both terrifying and unpredictable. This is done differently to the style of Tarantino. Yet, emotions are truly heightened through the character of Rosie the elephant who will become the object of a power struggle both within the circus and in Marlena’s heart. Animal lovers, this film is for you.

So yes, with its familiar themes and melodramatic moments (which are tastefully done and not too pronounced), this new Francis Lawrence creation is one of those romantic movies that will quickly find its way into people’s hearts. It demonstrates that classicism in a movie is not always a drawback. Water for Elephants is like one of those candies that, provided it is not eaten too often, can bring the most wonderful dream to life.

About deb24601

I write stuff. About books, music, movies... occasionally about Robert Pattinson. *whistles* I blog with and
This entry was posted in The Reviews, Water for Elephants and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to REVIEW: From FilmsActu “Good news for fans of romantic movies”

  1. Zuza says:

    Reviews like this one are all I wish for. I really hope they kept this story simple as it is and focused on the circus world instead of characters’ relations. Because the whole story is beautiful thanks to its simplicity.

  2. Janners says:

    This is a wonderful review! And not just because they liked it. Well written, concise, objective….let’s hope most of them will be like this one.

  3. RobCatCdn says:

    Great review overall … except for the reference to the voice over. Time will tell if I agree with that comment or not. :-) And about the new tab “promotion” (thanks for creating it) on the site … I look forward to reading or re-reading the reviews after I’ve seen it. ;-)

  4. roblover says:

    I love this review.

  5. Pingback: REVISIÓN: Desde FilmsActu "Buenas noticias para los fans de las películas románticas" « Mi Crepúsculo.

  6. Bettybmusing says:

    Love it :) very will written

Leave a Reply